Two tones / one scopeInterval figures, 16 Nov 2026
A perfect fifth draws a closed knot. A piano's fifth never closes.
Play two pure tones in a 3:2 ratio and plot one against the other: the pen retraces itself forever. Tune the upper tone the way a piano does and you miss by 1.96 cents. That is too small to hear as out of tune, yet the picture turns and never settles. Pick any interval below, watch it, and listen to it.
Perfect fifth 3:2
x = lower tone y = upper tone
pure ratio, closeslive tuning, drifts
Piano ratio1.4983
Pure ratio1.5000
Off by-1.96 c
Beats per second0.74
The dashed knot is the pure 3:2 figure. The bright one is the same fifth tuned on a piano: its shape keeps cycling, once per beat.
Guess first
Which of these does a piano tune furthest from its pure ratio?
Tune it
Higher notes beat faster, because the mismatch is a fixed share of the frequency. Slide the lower tone and watch the beat count.
Every step of the scale, measured
Piano (12-tone equal temperament) minus pure ratio, in cents. One cent is 1/100 of a semitone. Tap a row to draw it.
Interval
Pure
Error, cents
Beats/s
How the figure is drawn
For an interval with pure ratio p:q the knot is x = sin(2πq·s), y = sin(2π·p·k·s + φ) for one period s from 0 to 1. k is the tuned ratio divided by the pure ratio, so k = 1 means a perfectly closed knot. The phase φ turns at f2 - (p/q)·f1 hertz, and the whole shape repeats once per audible beat, |q·f2 - p·f1|. For the fifth at 220 Hz that is 0.74 beats a second, the same sum as the 660 Hz against 659.255 Hz example in the sources.
Sources and method
Pure (just intonation) ratios, equal temperament ratios 2n/12 and the tuning-error column: Wikipedia, "Equal temperament", section "Comparison with just intonation" (secondary source; the table cites Benson, Music: a mathematical offering, 2007). Read 16 Nov 2026.
Fifth: 3:2 pure versus 27/12, about 1.498; 660 Hz versus 659.255 Hz for the E above A440: Wikipedia, "Interval ratio". Read 16 Nov 2026 (secondary).
Figure family: Wikipedia, "Lissajous curve". Read 16 Nov 2026 (secondary).
Computed here, not copied: cents = 1200 x log2(ratio), beats = |q·f2 - p·f1|, all 13 errors recomputed and checked against the published column to within 0.01 cent. The lower tone defaults to 220 Hz (A3); the pure intervals use the 5-limit ratios from the table, other pure fourths and sevenths exist. Sine tones only.